Skip to content
Bog & Briar
Menu

Boot Fit & Sizing

Hunting boots or shoes?

Shoes are lighter and cooler and plenty of hunting gets done in them. The three things that force a boot are load, water and what is on the ground.

By Mike M.Last updated

Bog & Briar earns a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Prices come from Amazon and change; the date beside every price is when we last verified it. Full disclosure.

Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g from Irish Setter
Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g from Irish Setter

Top pick

Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g

9.3/10

Light miles in cool weather

A deliberately light 8-inch boot with just 400g of insulation - the right spec for an early-season walk-in where the problem is weight and sweat, not cold.

Quick picks

#ProductShaft heightScorePrice
Rank 1
Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g from Irish Setter

Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g

Light miles in cool weather

8 in9.3/10$199.95Amazon
Rank 2
Lowa Renegade EVO GTX Mid from Lowa

Lowa Renegade EVO GTX Mid

Wide-ish feet that need a hiker

Mid9.1/10$279.95Amazon
Rank 3
Salomon Quest 4 GTX from Salomon

Salomon Quest 4 GTX

Scouting miles in comfort

Not published9.0/10$219.90Amazon
Rank 4
Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX from Danner

Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX

Scouting and warm-weather miles

Not published9.1/10$233.81Amazon

#ad Prices come from Amazon and change. How this site is funded. Scores are our published editorial rubric — see our methodology.

Wear shoes when you are carrying nothing, on dry ground, in country with no venomous snakes and no thorn brush - and a boot the moment any one of those changes. The decision is not about toughness. A low-cut trail shoe is lighter, cooler and faster, and for scouting, dove fields, mild upland and most public-land walking it is genuinely enough. What a boot buys you is a stiffer platform under load, a shaft that keeps water and debris out, and coverage over the part of your leg that brush and snakes reach.

The reason this gets argued about is that "ankle support" is the usual justification and it is the weakest one. A mid-height boot restricts ankle roll somewhat; it does not prevent a sprain, and a strong ankle in a shoe is more stable than a weak ankle in a boot. The arguments that actually hold up are load, water and exposure.

The three things that force a boot

Load

A pack over about 35 lb changes the mechanics of every step. The force goes through a smaller area of your foot for longer, and a soft, flexible shoe midsole lets your arch collapse into it mile after mile. This is why mountain hunters wear stiff-shanked boots and why the same people wear trail runners to scout the same country in July. The stiffness is the point, not the height - see best mountain hunting boots.

Water and debris

A shoe has a collar at roughly ankle height, which is below every puddle, dew line, snow crust and seed head you will walk through. The boot's shaft is doing a mechanical job here that no membrane in a shoe can substitute for: it keeps the water from going in over the top. Grass seeds and burrs in a sock are the version of this that ruins a hunt without anyone calling it a failure.

What is on the ground

In country with venomous snakes, a shoe leaves the lower leg and ankle entirely exposed - which is precisely where outdoor-safety guidance puts the risk. In thorn brush, mesquite or catclaw, an ankle-height upper is shredded in a season. Both are coverage problems, and coverage is a height spec. If snakes are your reason, the answer is not a taller hunting boot but a purpose-built one: best snake boots for hunting.

HuntShoes are fineBoots are betterWhy
Summer scouting, dry trailsYes-No load, no water, speed matters
Dove fieldsYes-Short walks, warm weather
Early upland on dry groundYesMarginalBurrs and seed heads are the deciding factor
Whitetail from a stand-YesScent, wet entry routes, standing still
Elk or mule deer with a pack-YesLoad and side-hill stability
Marsh, flooded timber, snow-YesWater over the collar ends the argument
Snake country-YesCoverage over the lower leg and ankle
Packing out meat-YesThe heaviest load you will ever carry
Where we would draw the line. Terrain and load decide it, not toughness

If the answer is boots, start here

A light 8-inch boot, a forgiving mid, the most comfortable long-mileage option, and the uninsulated hunting-pattern hiker.

#1 · Light miles in cool weather

Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g

Irish Setter
9.3/10

A deliberately light 8-inch boot with just 400g of insulation - the right spec for an early-season walk-in where the problem is weight and sweat, not cold.

Published specifications
Insulation400g
Shaft height8 in
UpperLeather and nylon
WaterproofingUltraDry membrane (manufacturer)
FitLace-up

Specifications per Irish Setter published specifications.

What it does well

  • Genuinely light for an insulated boot, which is the whole point of the model
  • Breaks in faster than a full-leather 12-inch boot

Good to know

  • 400g and an 8-inch shaft is not a cold-sit boot - read the spec and believe it

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
6.2
Waterproofing
7.8
Fit
9.0
Durability
8.0
Value
8.6

#2 · Wide-ish feet that need a hiker

Lowa Renegade EVO GTX Mid

Lowa
9.1/10

The most-sold hiking boot in its class for a reason: a forgiving last, a genuine Gore-Tex membrane, and almost no break-in.

Published specifications
InsulationNone (uninsulated)
Shaft heightMid
UpperNubuck leather
WaterproofingGore-Tex (manufacturer)
WidthsStandard and wide offered

What it does well

  • Available in a true wide, which rules most hunting boots out of contention
  • Comfortable immediately

Good to know

  • Uninsulated and mid-height - a three-season scouting boot only

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
3.2
Waterproofing
8.6
Fit
9.6
Durability
8.6
Value
7.8

#3 · Scouting miles in comfort

Salomon Quest 4 GTX

Salomon
9.0/10

A backpacking boot, not a hunting boot - and the most comfortable way to put twelve miles on your feet in warm weather that this list contains.

Published specifications
InsulationNone (uninsulated)
Shaft heightNot published by manufacturer
UpperLeather and textile
WaterproofingGore-Tex (manufacturer)
ChassisAdvanced Chassis (manufacturer)

What it does well

  • Essentially no break-in
  • Carries a pack far better than its weight suggests

Good to know

  • Textile upper is the wrong thing to drag through briar

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
3.0
Waterproofing
8.6
Fit
9.6
Durability
7.8
Value
8.2

#4 · Scouting and warm-weather miles

Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX

Danner
9.1/10

Not a hunting boot in the insulated sense - an uninsulated Gore-Tex hiker that happens to be the right tool for August scouting and September archery.

Published specifications
InsulationNone (uninsulated)
Shaft heightNot published by manufacturer
UpperSuede leather
WaterproofingGore-Tex (manufacturer)
OutsoleVibram SPE/Megagrip

Specifications per Danner published specifications.

What it does well

  • Comfortable out of the box in a way no insulated hunting boot is
  • Vibram Megagrip is the best wet-rock outsole in this list

Good to know

  • Zero insulation - this is the wrong boot the moment it gets cold

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
3.0
Waterproofing
8.6
Fit
9.4
Durability
8.4
Value
8.4

The honest case for shoes

Weight on your feet costs several times more energy than the same weight on your back, which is why ultralight backpackers abandoned boots years ago. On a long, dry, unloaded walk a trail shoe is simply faster and less tiring, and it is cooler, which matters in September more than most hunters admit. A lot of "my boots killed me" is really "I wore a 1,000g insulated boot to scout in August".

  1. Scouting is not hunting. Scout in shoes and hunt in boots; they are different activities with different footwear.
  2. Blisters come from moisture and motion, not from low-cut uppers. A wicking sock does more than a taller boot - see why cotton socks fail.
  3. A mid-height boot is the compromise most hunters actually want. An 8 to 9-inch lace-up gets you the shaft without the weight of a 12-inch one.
  4. Two pairs beat one compromise. A shoe for miles and a boot for the hunt costs less than one boot that fails at both.

Where hiking boots fit into this

Three of the four picks on this page are hiking boots rather than hunting boots, which is deliberate: an uninsulated hiker is the right tool for most warm-weather hunting, and the hunting-specific features you give up are camo and scent control. Whether that trade works for your hunt is the subject of hunting boots or hiking boots, and the warm-weather picks are in best hunting boots for hot weather.

The short answer

  • No pack, dry ground, no snakes, no thorns: shoes.
  • Pack over about `35 lb`: boots, and stiff ones.
  • Water, snow or heavy dew: boots, and tall enough to clear it.
  • Snakes or thorn brush: boots, and specifically tall ones.
  • Sitting still in the cold: boots, insulated - a shoe has nowhere to put loft.
  • Unsure: a mid-height uninsulated boot covers more cases than either extreme.

Our recommendation

If you only take one thing from this page, take this one.

Our pick

Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g

Light miles in cool weather

9.3/10

Runner-up

Lowa Renegade EVO GTX Mid

Wide-ish feet that need a hiker

9.1/10

Frequently asked questions

Can you hunt in shoes instead of boots?
Yes, for a lot of hunting. If you are carrying nothing, on dry ground, in country with no venomous snakes and no thorn brush, a trail shoe is lighter, cooler and faster. Load over about 35 lb, water or snow over the collar, and snake or thorn exposure are the three things that genuinely force a boot.
Do hunting boots prevent ankle sprains?
Not reliably. A mid-height boot restricts ankle roll somewhat but does not prevent a sprain, and a stiff boot can transfer force up the leg instead of absorbing it. Buy a boot for the shaft height, the midsole stiffness and the coverage - ankle support is the weakest of the usual arguments.
Are hiking shoes good enough for hunting?
For scouting, dove fields and mild dry upland, yes - and they are better than an insulated hunting boot in warm weather. What you give up is camo, scent control and the shaft that keeps water and seed heads out, so they are a poor choice for stand hunting, marsh, snow or snake country.
What height hunting boot should I buy?
An 8 to 9-inch lace-up covers the most cases: it gives you a shaft without the weight of a 12-inch boot. Go to 16 to 18 inches for water, snow or scent control on a stand, and to 16 to 17 inches specifically for snake protection, which is a coverage requirement rather than a comfort preference.
Is it worth owning both hunting shoes and boots?
Usually yes, and it often costs less than one boot that tries to do both jobs. A light shoe for summer scouting and long dry miles, plus a boot matched to your actual season, solves more problems than a single compromise pair - which typically ends up too warm for August and too light for November.

Sources

Lowa Renegade EVO GTX Mid from Lowa

Boot Fit & Sizing

Hunting boots or hiking boots

In mild weather on open ground a hiker is often the better hunting boot. Exactly where that stops being true.

Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX from Danner

Boot Fit & Sizing

Best hunting boots for hot weather

Almost every boot on the hunting wall is insulated, which is the wrong spec in heat. Six uninsulated picks for scouting, archery and Southern seasons.

Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX from Danner

Boot Fit & Sizing

Best hunting boots for hiking

If you walk more than you sit, most of the hunting aisle is wrong for you. What works, and when to buy a hiker.

Danner Sharptail 17-inch Snake Boot from Danner

Snake Boots

The best snake boots for hunting

Six boots ranked on coverage and whether you will still be wearing them in August - which is what actually protects you.

Hunting boots sorted by the problem you actually have — cold feet, wet feet, or snakes.