Skip to content
Bog & Briar
Menu

Brands

Danner vs Irish Setter

Two American hunting-boot names that land in the same search and sit at different prices. The decision is mostly about what you are paying for underfoot - and about which membrane the maker is willing to name.

By Mike M.Last updated

Bog & Briar earns a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Prices come from Amazon and change; the date beside every price is when we last verified it. Full disclosure.

Danner Pronghorn 800g from Danner
Danner Pronghorn 800g from Danner

Head to head

Danner Pronghorn 800g

9.7/10

All-day walking in the cold

800g in Danner's Pronghorn platform, which is built around a supportive midsole rather than a soft one. The boot to buy if your hunt is measured in miles.

Quick picks

#ProductInsulationScorePrice
Rank 1
Danner Pronghorn 800g from Danner

Danner Pronghorn 800g

All-day walking in the cold

800g9.7/10$319.95Amazon
Rank 2
Irish Setter Elk Tracker 12-inch, 1,000g from Irish Setter

Irish Setter Elk Tracker 12-inch, 1,000g

Cold-weather hunts that involve walking

1,000g9.6/10$279.95Amazon
Rank 3
Danner Vital 8-inch, 400g from Danner

Danner Vital 8-inch, 400g

A cheaper Danner for early season

400g Thinsulate Ultra9.3/10$219.95Amazon
Rank 4
Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g from Irish Setter

Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g

Light miles in cool weather

400g9.3/10$199.95Amazon
Rank 5
Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX from Danner

Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX

Scouting and warm-weather miles

None (uninsulated)9.1/10$233.81Amazon
Rank 6
Irish Setter MudTrek 17-inch from Irish Setter

Irish Setter MudTrek 17-inch

A full-fit rubber boot that walks

Not published9.5/10$199.95Amazon

#ad Prices come from Amazon and change. How this site is funded. Scores are our published editorial rubric — see our methodology.

Buy Danner if you want a named membrane and a rebuildable platform and you will pay for it; buy Irish Setter if you want most of the boot for meaningfully less money. That is the short version, and the gap between the two brands is narrower than the price difference suggests on anything except the top of Danner's range.

The two names collide in search because they occupy the same shelf in the same stores and both have been making hunting boots for a long time. They are not the same proposition. The clearest way to separate them is to look at what each maker is willing to print on the box.

Three matched pairs

A Danner and an Irish Setter at each of three jobs: the cold walk, the light early-season boot, and the water boot. Every figure is the maker's own.

#1 · All-day walking in the cold

Danner Pronghorn 800g

Danner
9.7/10

800g in Danner's Pronghorn platform, which is built around a supportive midsole rather than a soft one. The boot to buy if your hunt is measured in miles.

Published specifications
Insulation800g
Shaft heightNot published by manufacturer
UpperLeather and nylon
WaterproofingGore-Tex (manufacturer)
OutsoleDanner Pronghorn

Specifications per Danner published specifications.

What it does well

  • One of the few insulated boots that genuinely supports a loaded pack
  • Gore-Tex plus a recraftable platform - this is a multi-season purchase
  • 800g walks far better than 1,000g or more

Good to know

  • Expensive, and the wide sizes are the ones that go out of stock

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
8.0
Waterproofing
8.8
Fit
9.4
Durability
9.4
Value
7.8

#2 · Cold-weather hunts that involve walking

Irish Setter Elk Tracker 12-inch, 1,000g

Irish Setter
9.6/10

1,000g of insulation in a 12-inch lace-up leather boot: the combination that lets you cover ground in the cold without the sweat-then-freeze cycle a rubber pull-on forces.

Published specifications
Insulation1,000g
Shaft height12 in
UpperFull-grain leather
WaterproofingUltraDry membrane (manufacturer)
FitLace-up

Specifications per Irish Setter published specifications.

What it does well

  • Laces mean you can actually tension the boot to your foot, which is why it walks better than any pull-on
  • 1,000g is the sweet spot for a boot you walk in and then sit in
  • Leather takes a real conditioning treatment and lasts seasons longer than neoprene

Good to know

  • Leather is not scent-free the way rubber is, and it absorbs whatever you walk through

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
8.8
Waterproofing
7.8
Fit
9.2
Durability
9.2
Value
8.2

#3 · A cheaper Danner for early season

Danner Vital 8-inch, 400g

Danner
9.3/10

Danner's value platform: 400g, a lighter build, and a price that does not assume you hunt for a living. Early and mid-season only.

Published specifications
Insulation400g Thinsulate Ultra
Shaft height8 in
UpperLeather and 900-denier polyester
WaterproofingDanner Dry (manufacturer)
FitLace-up

Specifications per Danner published specifications.

What it does well

  • Light, flexible and barely needs breaking in
  • The cheapest way into a boot that walks properly

Good to know

  • Not recraftable like Danner's stitchdown boots

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
6.2
Waterproofing
8.4
Fit
8.8
Durability
8.0
Value
8.6

#4 · Light miles in cool weather

Irish Setter VaprTrek 8-inch, 400g

Irish Setter
9.3/10

A deliberately light 8-inch boot with just 400g of insulation - the right spec for an early-season walk-in where the problem is weight and sweat, not cold.

Published specifications
Insulation400g
Shaft height8 in
UpperLeather and nylon
WaterproofingUltraDry membrane (manufacturer)
FitLace-up

Specifications per Irish Setter published specifications.

What it does well

  • Genuinely light for an insulated boot, which is the whole point of the model
  • Breaks in faster than a full-leather 12-inch boot

Good to know

  • 400g and an 8-inch shaft is not a cold-sit boot - read the spec and believe it

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
6.2
Waterproofing
7.8
Fit
9.0
Durability
8.0
Value
8.6

#5 · Scouting and warm-weather miles

Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX

Danner
9.1/10

Not a hunting boot in the insulated sense - an uninsulated Gore-Tex hiker that happens to be the right tool for August scouting and September archery.

Published specifications
InsulationNone (uninsulated)
Shaft heightNot published by manufacturer
UpperSuede leather
WaterproofingGore-Tex (manufacturer)
OutsoleVibram SPE/Megagrip

Specifications per Danner published specifications.

What it does well

  • Comfortable out of the box in a way no insulated hunting boot is
  • Vibram Megagrip is the best wet-rock outsole in this list

Good to know

  • Zero insulation - this is the wrong boot the moment it gets cold

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
3.0
Waterproofing
8.6
Fit
9.4
Durability
8.4
Value
8.4

#6 · A full-fit rubber boot that walks

Irish Setter MudTrek 17-inch

Irish Setter
9.5/10

Irish Setter's rubber boot, built on a full-fit last rather than the loose tube most pull-ons use - which is why it walks better than its height suggests.

Published specifications
InsulationNot published by manufacturer
Shaft height17 in
UpperRubber over neoprene
FitFull fit, pull-on
WidthsStandard and wide offered

Specifications per Irish Setter published specifications.

What it does well

  • A wide option, which almost no knee-high rubber boot offers
  • The full-fit last means less heel slip, so fewer blisters on a long walk-in

Good to know

  • Insulation varies by listing; check before buying for cold

Our rubric — each criterion 0-10

Warmth
6.8
Waterproofing
9.0
Fit
8.8
Durability
8.4
Value
8.6

The core difference, in one table

 DannerIrish Setter
Waterproofing on the flagshipGore-Tex, named on the PronghornUltraDry, the brand's own membrane
Entry-price waterproofingDanner Dry on the VitalUltraDry on the VaprTrek
Insulation range listed here400g to 1,200g400g to 1,000g
Typical price positionHigherLower for a comparable rating
Rubber boot in the lineNot in this registryMudTrek, 17 in, standard and wide
WidthsVaries by modelMudTrek offered in standard and wide
Best atA named membrane and a boot you keepGetting the same gram figure for less
Published manufacturer specifications for the models this site carries. The membrane row is the one most buyers are actually deciding on

The membrane is the real decision

Danner names Gore-Tex on the Pronghorn. Irish Setter uses UltraDry, which is its own membrane, and Danner uses Danner Dry on the cheaper Vital - so two of the three are house membranes with no third-party name attached.

This matters less on day one than the marketing implies and more in year three than buyers expect. A new boot of either kind keeps water out. The difference shows up in how long the membrane keeps doing it, and a licensed membrane carries a specification the boot maker had to meet, where a house membrane carries the maker's word. Neither of those is a lie; they are different kinds of promise, and one of them is cheaper.

Pair one: the cold walk

The Danner Pronghorn at 800g with Gore-Tex against the Irish Setter Elk Tracker at 1,000g with UltraDry behind 12 in of full-grain leather. On paper the Elk Tracker is the warmer boot by 200g and the taller one by a clear margin, and it usually costs less.

The Pronghorn's argument is the rest of the boot: a named membrane, Danner's own Pronghorn outsole, and a platform with a service life that justifies the money if you hunt hard. If you want the warmest boot for the fewest dollars, the Elk Tracker wins this pair outright. If you want the boot you still own in five years, the argument flips.

Pair two: the light early-season boot

The Danner Vital at 400g Thinsulate Ultra behind Danner Dry, against the Irish Setter VaprTrek at 400g behind UltraDry. Both are 8 in lace-ups, both sit near the same money, and both are built the light way - leather with a synthetic panel rather than full leather.

There is no meaningful specification gap here, which makes this the purest fit decision on the page. Try both. If you cannot, buy the brand whose boots have fit you before, because at this price the last matters more than the membrane. Both appear in best lightweight hunting boots with the weight question handled properly.

Pair three: the water boot, where only one brand shows up

Irish Setter makes the MudTrek, a 17 in rubber-over-neoprene pull-on offered in standard and wide. Danner has no equivalent in this registry, so this is less a comparison than a gap: if you need a knee-high rubber boot, Irish Setter is the one of the two that sells you one.

The MudTrek's genuinely useful feature is the wide option, because calf fit is the thing that defeats most hunters in a 17-inch pull-on. Rubber boots for wide calves is the fuller treatment, and best rubber hunting boots ranks the category by water depth.

Outsoles, and the part of the boot you stand on

Danner names its outsoles and treats them as part of the product: the Pronghorn carries Danner's own Pronghorn outsole, and the Mountain 600 runs a Vibram SPE/Megagrip unit, which is a licensed compound with a reputation on wet rock. Irish Setter is quieter about what is underfoot across the models here.

This is the same pattern as the membrane question and it has the same answer: a named component is a specification you can look up, and an unnamed one is the maker's word. On flat farmland it changes nothing. On wet rock, blowdown and steep leaf litter it is the difference between confidence and caution, which is why the Mountain 600 is the one boot in this comparison that hunters buy for a reason unrelated to hunting.

Service life, and the only honest way to compare price

A boot's real cost is per season, not per pair. That calculation only favors the dearer brand if the boot actually lasts longer, and the thing that decides it is construction rather than badge.

  • Cemented construction cannot be rebuilt. When the sole goes, the boot is done. Most light boots in both lines are built this way, and that is a reasonable trade at this price.
  • A rebuildable platform changes the arithmetic - but only if you will actually send the boots away and pay for it, which most hunters do not. Be honest with yourself about that before paying for the option.
  • Membrane failure usually ends a boot before the sole does. This is the practical argument for a named membrane, and it is the strongest card Danner holds.
  • Neither brand survives being stored wet. Drying matters more to boot life than brand does - see how long do hunting boots last.

Sizing between the two

Both are American lasts in US sizing, so there is no conversion trap here of the kind a European boot creates. What there is instead is model-to-model variation inside each brand, which catches people who assume their size in one Danner carries to another.

Size both over the sock you will hunt in, in the afternoon, and expect a lace-up 8 in boot and a 12 in insulated boot from the same maker to want different amounts of room. What size boot over thick socks is the short method, and the sizing guide is the long one.

Where Danner is worth the money, and where it is not

  • Worth it: you want Gore-Tex named on the box, you hunt enough that the boot's service life is a real cost, or you want the Mountain 600 as a scouting boot that doubles as a hiker.
  • Worth it: you have had house membranes wet out on you before and you would rather buy the specification than the promise.
  • Not worth it: you want the highest gram rating per dollar. Irish Setter wins that comparison in this registry and it is not close.
  • Not worth it: you need a knee-high rubber boot, which Danner does not offer here at all.
  • Neither, if you are sitting still below freezing. Both brands top out lower than a dedicated cold-sit boot - that is a 1,200g or rubber-pull-on problem.

The honest summary

Irish Setter is the better value brand and Danner is the better-specified one, and for most hunters most of the time the value argument is the right one. The exception is narrow and real: if the boot is going to be worn hard for many seasons, the brand that names its membrane and builds a platform worth rebuilding is cheaper per season even though it is dearer per pair.

Both brands have their own page here with the full model line and the gaps in each spec sheet - Danner and Irish Setter.

Our recommendation

If you only take one thing from this page, take this one.

Our pick

Danner Pronghorn 800g

All-day walking in the cold

9.7/10

Runner-up

Irish Setter Elk Tracker 12-inch, 1,000g

Cold-weather hunts that involve walking

9.6/10

Frequently asked questions

Is Danner better than Irish Setter?
Not in a general sense. Danner names Gore-Tex on its flagship Pronghorn and builds platforms with a longer service life; Irish Setter gives you a higher published insulation figure for less money, and it is the only one of the two that makes a knee-high rubber boot in this registry. Danner is the better-specified brand, Irish Setter the better value one.
Is UltraDry as good as Gore-Tex?
UltraDry is Irish Setter's own membrane rather than a licensed one, so it carries the maker's word instead of a third-party specification. Both keep water out when the boot is new. The difference buyers report is in longevity rather than in day-one performance, and neither membrane addresses sweat from the inside.
Which brand runs wider?
It depends on the model rather than the brand, and neither publishes a width chart that covers the whole line. In this registry the Irish Setter MudTrek is the one model explicitly offered in standard and wide. If width is your constraint, start from best hunting boots for wide feet rather than from a brand.
Are Danner and Irish Setter the same company?
They are separate brands with separate product lines and separate published specifications, and this page compares them on what each one publishes for the models sold today. Corporate ownership does not change which membrane is named on which boot, which is the thing worth deciding on.

Sources

Danner Pronghorn 800g from Danner

Brands

Danner hunting boots

The maker to buy if you walk: recraftable platforms, Gore-Tex, and the best snake boot in the category.

Meindl EuroLight Hunter 300 from Meindl

Boot Fit & Sizing

Best lightweight hunting boots

Light boots ranked on the per-pair weights makers actually publish - and an honest account of the warmth, protection and support you trade to get there.

Irish Setter Elk Tracker 12-inch, 1,000g from Irish Setter

Cold Weather Boots

Best hunting boots for men

One boot for the whole season, routed by whether you walk or sit rather than by insulation grams. Seven picks, four boot types, live prices.

Hunting boots sorted by the problem you actually have — cold feet, wet feet, or snakes.